By: Scott A. Coffina , Mark T. Sottile
A sexual harassment case now before New Jersey’s Appellate Division could have significant implications for commercial landlords in New Jersey. Karen Lodzinski v. Fieldspring Investments, et al., concerns the novel question of whether the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination (“LAD”) protects a commercial tenant from a harassing landlord the same way it protects an employee from a harassing boss.
The dispute. Karen Lodzinski was 22 when she opened a boutique in a Point Pleasant storefront she leased from Fieldspring Investments and its managing member, Michael Stadler. According to her Complaint, Stadler — roughly 70 years old, with keys to the store and a habit of dropping in while she worked alone — began a steady stream of personal remarks in 2023. He told her she was “really beautiful,” texted that she was a “cutie” with “mesmerizing” teeth, said he admired her “like you are a piece of art,” and eventually messaged, “Will you marry me?” She says she told him it was inappropriate (which he acknowledged it was), and she stopped feeling safe alone in her own store, leading her finally to break her lease and move out in September 2024, approximately four months before her lease was due to expire.
Ms. Lodzinski brought an action against Fieldspring and its managing member, Mr. Stadler, alleging his conduct violated Section 10:5-12(g) of the LAD, which states in relevant part that it is unlawful discrimination for any person, including any owner, lessee, or someone with the right to lease real property “to discriminate against any person based on . . . sex . . . in the terms, conditions, or privileges of the . . . rental . . . of real property. . . .” Ms. Lodzinski’s contention is that Mr. Stadler’s allegedly harassing conduct was pervasive enough to alter the terms and conditions of her lease, creating a hostile environment that denied her the privileges of her lease for her store.
Fieldspring and Stadler moved to dismiss the LAD Complaint, arguing that there was no quid pro quo for sexual favors or threat by the landlord to refuse to rent the storefront or to interfere with necessities like heat or water. Ms. Lodzinski responded that defendants missed the point of her Complaint, which is that Stadler’s alleged harassment was severe or pervasive enough to alter the terms and conditions of her lease and create an intimidating, hostile, and abusive environment for her use and enjoyment of the commercial property. Defendants replied – in addition to dismissing Stadler’s conduct as “failed pick-up lines” – that there are no cases finding a hostile work environment in the context of a commercial landlord-tenant relationship. The trial court then dismissed Ms. Lodzinski’s Complaint, finding no precedent applying the LAD to conduct like Stadler’s.
On appeal, the plaintiff relies on the broad remedial purpose of the LAD, and cites the power imbalance between a 22-year-old woman working alone in her store, and the 70-year-old landlord to whom her livelihood, arguably, is beholden. The defendants, by contrast, continue to maintain that there must be a quid pro quo, i.e., “do this or I’ll turn your heat off,” for the LAD to apply to a commercial lease.
Our research did not identify a case where a sexual harassment/hostile work environment claim was recognized by a court in the context of a commercial landlord-tenant relationship. In JT’s Tire Service, Inc. v. United Rentals North America, Inc., 411 N.J. Super. 236 (App. Div. 2010), the court recognized a cause of action under the LAD in a setting where a branch manager of a rental company tried to extort sexual favors from the owner of a tire company as a condition of continuing their business relationship. Both parties in Lodzinski argued the applicability of JT’s Tire to their respective arguments, but notably, this case was brought under a different section of the LAD, Section 10:5-12(l) (prohibiting a refusal to do business with another on the basis of a protected characteristic), did not involve a landlord-tenant relationship, and involved a quid pro quo, not a hostile work environment.
The closest factual analog we found outside New Jersey is People ex rel. City of Santa Monica v. Gabriel, 186 Cal. App. 4th 882, (2010), a California case holding that a landlord’s sexual harassment of a tenant constituted an unlawful “business practice” actionable under California’s Unfair Competition Law, not its antidiscrimination law. Notably, Gabriel involved a residential tenancy that the court characterized as a “commercial relationship” (i.e., the business dealings between landlord and tenant).
It is difficult to predict the outcome of the Lodzinski appeal. On the one hand, New Jersey courts continually emphasize the broad remedial purpose of the LAD; the landlord’s conduct arguably meets the language of Section 10:5-12(g) by interfering with the “privileges” of Ms. Lodzinski’s rental or real property; and the case was dismissed before discovery as to whether the landlord’s conduct created a hostile work environment for Ms. Lodzinski in her store. On the other hand, there was no quid pro quo threatening the bargained-for terms of Ms. Lodzinski’s lease, and the LAD has not previously been applied to a commercial landlord-tenant relationship.
It is well established that the LAD, and the Federal Housing Act, prohibit discrimination, including sexual harassment, in the residential context. But extending the application of the LAD to a hostile work environment claim in the context of a commercial lease would have significant implications. For one, it would create a new theory of landlord liability tying the landlord-tenant relationship to the standards of employment relationships, although those are substantially different settings. And commercial landlords and property managers would be exposed to the full remedial toolkit of the LAD, including injunctive relief, fee-shifting, and exposure to punitive damages.
Of course, tenants, like all people, should be free from sexual harassment wherever they are. But the relationship between an employer and employee is markedly different than most commercial landlord-tenant relationships, and typically easier for a tenant to mitigate. Perhaps one outcome of the Lodzinski case, whatever its result, will be to include the creation of a “hostile work environment” as a material breach of a lease, allowing the tenant to terminate their lease early.
We look forward to monitoring the Lodzinski appeal and will follow up once the Appellate Division renders its decision. For questions about this case or employment matters generally, please contact partners Scott Coffina or Mark Sottile, attorneys at Pietragallo Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti, LLP.